Ok, I've been testing out this cool lighting stuff everyone's been doing and I can't seem to get it down.  I tried it on my new sig but it came out like this.

It just looks odd to me.  It doesn't have that insane glossy effect like the rest do.  Maybe I'm going to minimal?  Idk.

Any tips etc would be appreciated! 

Edit:  You know, maybe if I actually spent more time trying I would get it.  O.o  I'm such a quicky runthrough person.  Lol.